Re: Devil's Advocate: American Revolution Campfire
If ye would like to moderate the American Revolution Campfire, please drop becket@jollyroger.com a
line. American Revolution & Re: Devil's Advocate
In Reply to: I'm late. posted by Scott Bubar on June 03, 192001 at 22:20:08:
: Well, Case, I'm afraid I'm a bit late in replying here. I'd intended to play devil's advocate and post the following:
: ___________
: "Yikes, I don't know where to start, Case.
: I thought you were going to ask a question about it.
: Below, you asked if I had read it. (Or perhaps you were asking folks more generally.)
: Well, the answer is: Yes, I have, but not in a long time, so far as I can recall. It used to hang on my wall when I was a kid. But it's still pretty much as I remember it.
: Since Tom put in such a long laundry list of complaints, I guess what occurs to me is: Were the British really so bad, or were they merely trying to recoup some of the losses from the war, and trying to pay for the defense of the continent?" And were the colonist reacting more to the affronts to their liberty, or to their pocketbook.
: Since were talking about the Declaration, let me rephrase that: Does it portray an accurate picture of the situation at the time? And does it provide sufficient justification for what is, in effect, a mutiny?" : _________________
: Of course, by the time the Declaration came out, events had already been taking a nasty turn for over a year. Prior to that, however, wasn't there still an awful lot of room for reconciliation?
: Boston could cave paid for that tea party, after all. ;)
I may have given you the wrong impression on my earlier post. In the beginning I was implying that there are people out there that really have not read the Declaration of Independence and jump too fast to the tax portion of the conflict without investigating any other facts....
Anyway, Devil's Advocate.... I like it :)
Give me some time and I will get back to you, if you still want to play...